Blizzard: Allowing pirate WoW servers would “damage [our] rights”

Found on Ars Technica on Tuesday, 26 April 2016
Browse Legal-Issues

Weeks after forcing the shutdown of a popular, fan-run "pirate" server that ran a classic version of World of Warcraft, Blizzard now says it basically had no choice but to go after Nostalrius to protect its legal rights.

In his post, Brack goes on to say that Blizzard has looked into running a Nostalrius-style "classic" server on its own, but that "none could be executed without great difficulty. If we could push a button and all of this would be created, we would. However, there are tremendous operational challenges to integrating classic servers, not to mention the ongoing support of multiple live versions for every aspect of WoW."

Funny how a couple of fans have more knowledge about WoW servers than Blizzard and were able to maintain it for years, for hundreds of thousands of users. Blizzard could simply give Nostalrius a special license and all would be good. Fans would be happy, legal rights would be protected.

Want to sue Ashley Madison over data breach? You must use your real name

Found on Ars Technica on Tuesday, 19 April 2016
Browse Legal-Issues

The massive litigation has been co-mingled in Missouri, and there are some interesting elements at play. For starters, the judge presiding over the case says that if you want to be a named plaintiff in the litigation, you can't use a pseudonym like "John Doe," and instead you have to use your real name.

Attorneys want to use confidential communications between Ashley Madison executives and their attorneys as part of their lawsuit in a bid to establish that the company made fake female profiles to induce people to become one of the site's 39 million members.

You have to use your real name in front of a court, and companies use fake profiles to attract paying users. There is nothing really new or shocking about that.

Uber for women is a great idea—except for one thing

Found on Quartz on Sunday, 10 April 2016
Browse Legal-Issues

A new women-only ride-sharing service, Chariot for Women, is set to launch April 19 in Boston, Massachusetts. Surprisingly, its founder is not a former female passenger who felt unsafe in an Uber—as many of us have—but Michael Pelletz, an Uber driver who had a revelation when he felt threatened by a passenger.

Scores of women have reported rapes and assaults by Uber drivers, while, anecdotally, countless others have felt threatened.

According to civil rights lawyers, Chariots for Women’s female-only policies could put it squarely in the crosshairs of gender discrimination lawsuits, which would be difficult to win.

Just imagine someone would start a male-only ride-sharing service. Lawsuits and threats would rain in non-stop.

Blizzard shuts down popular fan-run “pirate” server for classic WoW

Found on Ars Technica on Thursday, 07 April 2016
Browse Legal-Issues

One of the most popular "pirate" servers for World of Warcraft, running a classic version of the game no longer offered by Blizzard, will be shutting down under the threat of legal action from Blizzard.

The administrators say that 800,000 registered accounts and 150,000 active players were working through quest progressions reproduced to precisely match the game of a decade ago.

Hosting private servers is explicitly against Blizzard's Terms of Use, a rule the company says "isn’t an issue because of ‘lost’ subscription fees from players choosing these illegitimate servers over the real WoW servers—it simply boils down to the fact that private servers are illegal, and that’s that."

Legally correct? Most likely. A wise decision? Most unlikely. At least 150,000 very miffed users are now out there who will not just jump on the new WoW bandwagon and abandon the game they like. If Blizzard truly thinks that it's not about the lost fees, it could have just ignored the fandom.

Reddit deletes surveillance 'warrant canary' in transparency report

Found on Reuters on Friday, 01 April 2016
Browse Legal-Issues

Social networking forum reddit on Thursday removed a section from its site used to tacitly inform users it had never received a certain type of U.S. government surveillance request, suggesting the platform is now being asked to hand over customer data under a secretive law enforcement authority.

"I've been advised not to say anything one way or the other," a reddit administrator named "spez," who made the update, said in a thread discussing the change. “Even with the canaries, we're treading a fine line.”

It should not be much of a surprise. In fact it's more of a suprise that it has not happened sooner.

Man who confronted Muslim woman to 'explain' Brussels attacks arrested

Found on The Guardian on Thursday, 24 March 2016
Browse Legal-Issues

A man who sparked an outcry on Twitter after tweeting about confronting a Muslim woman on a street in Croydon, south London, and challenging her to “explain Brussels” has been arrested by police.

Officers for the Metropolitan police in Croydon tweeted on Wednesday that a suspect had been arrested for inciting racial hatred.

That will do more harm than good. A lot of people already think that officials and politicians are tiptoeing around this topic and censoring free speech, and actions like that will support their views.

It's official: Lavabit fell on its sword protecting Edward Snowden

Found on The Inquirer on Sunday, 20 March 2016
Browse Legal-Issues

Even though a gagging order has prevented Ladar Levison who owned Lavabit, or any of his team from spilling, it now appears that the Feds have done it themselves.

His stance cost him dearly, with by his own estimates 410,000 registered users with many paying for encrypted storage, and denying him his main source of income. Levison wanted to be able to explain what happened.

Should Levison decide to restart his business in a more friendly country, his stance could quickly bring him a lot of customers, old and new.

Elsevier and the Streisand Effect

Found on DSHR's Blog on Saturday, 19 March 2016
Browse Legal-Issues

Then last June Elsevier filed a case in New York trying to shut down Library Genesis and Sci-Hub. Both are apparently based in Russia, which is not highly motivated to send more of its foreign reserves to Western publishers. So the case was not effective at shutting them down. It turned out, however, to be a classic case of the Streisand Effect, in which attempting to suppress information on the Web causes it to attract far more attention.

Last weekend the Streisand Effect reached the opinion pages of the New York Times with Kate Murphy's Should All Research Papers Be Free?, replete with quotes from Michael Eisen, Alicia Wise, Peter Suber and David Crotty. Alas, Murphy starts by writing "Her protest against scholarly journals’ paywalls". Sci-Hub isn't a protest. Calling something a protest is a way of labelling it ineffectual. Sci-Hub is a tool that implements a paywall-free world.

Access to scientific material should not be hindered, if you want research to be free and independent.

Florida sheriff says he'll jail 'rascal' Tim Cook

Found on CNet News on Sunday, 13 March 2016
Browse Legal-Issues

"I can tell you, the first time we do have trouble getting into a cell phone, we're going to seek a court order from Apple," he said. "And when they deny us, I'm going to go lock the CEO of Apple up. I'll lock the rascal up."

When once asked why his officers had shot at a suspect 110 times, hitting him 68 times, he explained that it was "all the ammunition they had."

Ain't he a cute little foot stomper? Pretty sure he would jail Cook too if Apple would decrypt a phone to obey a court order in, let's say, Russia; but for treason.

1,845 Cases Filed For 'Insulting' Turkish President In Just 18 Months

Found on Techdirt on Tuesday, 08 March 2016
Browse Legal-Issues

The stories keep on coming about prosecutions for "insulting" Erdogan. The most insane one started making news a few weeks ago, when a Turkish man filed a complaint against his own wife for apparently insulting Erdogan in their home.

Incredibly, it appears that such complaints, which need to be approved by the Justice Ministry are coming in at a rate of over 1,000 per month.

Dictators do not take insults lightly; and now that the EU needs him, none of the officials will really complain much.